Society & safeguards

€805 Million Fine for Facebook, Which Got Into Photo Galleries

And this time, Meta couldn't hide behind Ireland.

6 min read
€805 Million Fine for Facebook, Which Got Into Photo Galleries

You're scrolling Facebook on your phone, and the app slips you a suggestion: a photo from your gallery, ready to post. You didn't pick it. It came from somewhere you thought was closed off. On Android, in Italy, that little courtesy has just cost Meta 805 million euros.

The Garante, Italy's data protection authority, announced the fine on November 14. Its press release says nothing about what Meta did with those photos. It goes after how the app got the key in the first place. And the Garante kept the case. The fine targets Meta Platforms Ireland, the subsidiary that carries the group in Europe from Dublin. Meta wanted the Irish regulator to handle it, as usually happens with its privacy cases. The Garante said no, on the strength of a different rule.

One key for the whole house

The feature at the center of the case suggests photos and videos from the phone's gallery as post ideas while you browse Facebook. It has existed since 2023. To work, it has to read the photos, the videos and their metadata.

According to the Garante, Facebook asked for that access through a single permission, valid for the entire app and for several features with different purposes. Just before it, a generic notice talked about "enabling other features," without making clear that gallery suggestions were among them. And the feature was on by default.

Picture a key ring where one key opens the cellar, the attic and the bedside drawer. Once granted in full, the authority writes, this kind of permission lets the app read the entire photo library, generally on an ongoing basis, with neither the user nor the regulator able to check what is actually being used.

The investigation began in July 2025 after a complaint from the Bolzano consumer protection centre, and the authority ran its own technical analysis. About 20 million Android users in Italy are affected.

What 805 million weighs

The amount equals about 0.47% of the group's worldwide revenue, the Garante says. To set it, the authority weighed the number of people affected, the length of the violation (still ongoing for anyone who hasn't updated the app or had already granted the permission), a 2019 ruling against Meta, and little cooperation during the investigation. Fixes made after the complaint counted in Meta's favour, but the authority found them late and limited to people who update the app.

POLITICO Europe reports that it is by far the largest fine the Italian regulator has ever imposed. Across Europe, it still trails the €824.99 million the Dutch authority imposed on Uber, and the €1.2 billion Ireland imposed on Meta over data transfers to the United States.

Meta is pushing back. "We strongly disagree with the Garante's assessment of the facts and its application of the law, and we consider the amount of the fine disproportionate," a company spokesperson told the Adnkronos news agency the same day (the quote is translated from the Italian). Meta describes a simple feature that helps people post, which users must allow on their phone before it works and can switch off at any time in settings. It says it will appeal.

Why Ireland didn't get a say

Meta's European headquarters are in Dublin. Under the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), that means the Irish regulator normally leads on cases against it, no matter which country the complaint comes from. That's the one-stop shop. You could see it at work with Uber, where a complaint from French drivers ended up being handled in Amsterdam. Meta invoked the mechanism before the Garante, which set it aside.

The reason is the rule it applied: Article 122 of the Italian privacy code, which transposes the EU's ePrivacy Directive. That directive protects the device itself. A phone is part of a person's private sphere, the Garante recalls, and any access to what's inside requires free and informed consent, whether or not data is transmitted and whether or not harm follows. And ePrivacy has no one-stop shop.

The GDPR follows the data wherever it goes and hands the case to the country of the headquarters. ePrivacy guards the door of the device. Italy isn't inventing anything here. As early as 2019, the European Data Protection Board (EDPB), which brings the national authorities together, wrote that the GDPR's cooperation mechanisms don't apply to enforcement of the ePrivacy Directive. And France's CNIL has already gone through that door: in late 2021 it fined Facebook Ireland 60 million euros and Google 150 million over cookie banners, setting the one-stop shop aside too, according to the law firm DLA Piper's analysis.

What the investigation didn't look at

The Garante takes care to say that the proceedings did not cover any use of this content to train artificial intelligence, which Meta denies. It reserves the right to examine separately a new feature, launched in 2026, that processes gallery content in the cloud.

The press release doesn't say whether any photos left the phones, either. The rule applied makes that question secondary: it's the access itself that is penalised.

AI is never far away, though. In June 2025, TechCrunch described a Facebook test that asked users to allow ongoing cloud processing of their camera roll, to generate collages and AI edits. In the app's settings, the gallery suggestions page carried two toggles at the time: one for the feature Italy has just sanctioned, the other for that cloud processing. Meta said back then that the images weren't being used to improve its models during the test. The Garante doesn't say whether the feature launched in 2026 is that one.

We've followed what Meta does with users' content for its AI, when the company rewrote a clause that worried the press and when Norwegian media sued it in Oslo. Here it's the front door on trial, before anyone knows what's behind it.

Sixty days to ask permission

Meta has 60 days to ask for separate, specific consent for the feature, explain what it's for, say that it requires gallery access, and say how to turn it off. It must stay off by default, including for people who had already agreed. After that deadline it can't be switched on for anyone who hasn't given valid consent. Meta must report on its first steps within 30 days and on the measures taken within 90.

The appeal will show whether Italy's way around the one-stop shop holds up before a judge. The next feature raises a tighter question.

Reading the gallery is a matter of the device's door. What happens afterwards on Meta's servers falls, in principle, under the GDPR, and the line the EDPB drew in 2019 then gives the one-stop shop its place back. Rome won the right to judge the lock. What happens behind the door, in the cloud, could well become Dublin's business again.

Was this article useful?

Topics covered:

PrivacyMetaAnalysis

Frequently asked questions

Why did Italy fine Meta 805 million euros?
According to the Garante's press release, the Italian data protection authority found that the Facebook app for Android accessed photos, videos and their metadata to suggest things to post, without specific consent. Access went through a single permission covering the whole app, behind a generic notice about enabling other features, and the feature was on by default. About 20 million Android users in Italy are affected.
Why didn't Ireland's regulator handle the case?
Under the GDPR, the regulator in the country of a company's EU headquarters, Ireland in Meta's case, normally leads: that's the one-stop shop. Meta invoked it and the Garante set it aside, because it applied Article 122 of the Italian privacy code, which transposes the ePrivacy Directive. That directive protects the device itself and has no one-stop shop. As early as 2019 the EDPB wrote that the GDPR's cooperation mechanisms don't apply to its enforcement, and according to law firm DLA Piper's analysis, France's CNIL also set the one-stop shop aside in late 2021 over cookie banners.
How does this fine compare with others in Europe?
It is not Europe's largest. POLITICO Europe reports it is by far the largest fine the Italian regulator has ever imposed. Across Europe it still sits behind the €824.99 million the Dutch authority imposed on Uber and the €1.2 billion Ireland imposed on Meta over data transfers to the United States. The amount equals about 0.47% of the group's worldwide revenue, according to the Garante.
Did Facebook use these photos to train its AI?
The investigation didn't look at that. The Garante says the proceedings did not cover any use of this content to train artificial intelligence, which Meta denies. The press release doesn't say whether any photos left the phones either: it is the access itself that was penalised. A new feature launched in 2026, which processes gallery content in the cloud, will be examined separately.
What does Meta have to do now?
Meta has 60 days to ask for separate, specific consent for the feature, explain what it does, and say how to switch it off. It must stay off by default, including for people who had already agreed. Meta must report back after 30 days, then after 90. The company disputes the amount, which it calls disproportionate, and says it will appeal.
Katja Liersch

Katja Liersch

Co-founder & Journalist

Katja is a journalist and TV producer. With decades of experience in mainstream media, she brings to Declic Media the perspective of those discovering AI: curious, demanding and pragmatic. She ensures every piece of content truly speaks to everyone.

All articles by Katja →
The free AI newsletter